Papa’s Bayside

· · 4 bedrooms · 2.5 bathrooms · 4000 sq ft

This family and pet friendly waterfront rental is one of the largest in our inventory.  Multiple families have enjoyed the spaciousness to spend quality time together or separately for re-energizing. You will have plenty of space to spread out, both indoors and outdoors at Papa’s Bayside.  Imagine summer days of swimming and enjoying the dock and evenings sitting around the campfire and waterfront seats for amazing sunsets.

After reading that… want to come stay at Papa’s Bayside, don’t you?!?!

Maximum Occupancy:

Kitchen, Living Room Dining Room Combination Family Room with walk out in the lower level

Main level: Full bath in master bedroom; half bath Downstairs: full bathroom with tub and shower


Main Level: Master: King bed with attached full bath, and with a crib;

Downstairs: Bedroom #1: 2 sets of bunk beds with Full on bottom and Twin on top; #2: Queen and Twin; #3: Queen; Lower level family room: Queen sofa sleeper and Twin sofa sleeper Lower Level Family Room: Queen Sofa Sleeper and Twin Sofa Sleeper

Pet Friendly:
Water access:
Write a review Review Bookmark this listing Bookmark

Availability calendar

Dates in Yellow are Tentatively Reserved. Dates in Red are Booked. All other dates are open.

Make inquiry now


  • **Furnishing and decor may change without notice.
  • **Sheets and towels not included.
  • 1 acre
  • 1 paddleboard
  • 1/3 acre
  • 2 dog kennels
  • 2 dogs allowed
  • 2 Stall Garage w/ Opener
  • 4000sqft
  • 40ft dock with L at end. Bench and ladder for access to water
  • 5 Minutes to Sturgeon Bay
  • Air Conditioning (Central)
  • Air Fryer
  • Beautifully Landscaped
  • Blender
  • Board Games
  • Breakfast Bar (4 Bar stools)
  • Cable TV (Basic)
  • Cathedral Ceilings
  • Coffee Maker
  • Crib in own room
  • Deck
  • Dishwasher
  • Dock
  • Exterior Power Outlets
  • Fans (Ceiling)
  • Fire Pit
  • Fireplace (Wood)
  • First Floor Entry
  • Garage (2 Stalls)
  • Garage - lawn games
  • Garbage Disposal
  • Gated area for dogs
  • Grill (Gas)
  • Hair Dryer
  • Hand weights
  • Hardwood Floors
  • Highchair
  • Ice Fishing nearby
  • Icemaker
  • Instapot
  • Iron
  • Ironing Board
  • Lawn Games
  • Life Jackets
  • Microwave
  • Mixer
  • Mooring ball
  • Nesco
  • Outdoor Furniture
  • Paddle Board (2)
  • Parking for vehicles + boat
  • Patio
  • Picnic Table
  • Precor exercise bike
  • Recliner
  • Rock Beach
  • Shed (lawn games& life jackets)
  • Spacious Backyard
  • Sunset View
  • Swing Set
  • Toaster
  • Toddler bed
  • TV (3)
  • Washer / Dryer
  • Water Accessible
  • Water View
  • Wi-Fi
  • Wood burning fireplace in LR
  • Year Round Rental
Seasonal Rental Rate May 22- Sept. 2 2024 4 night minimum May 27-June 15 2024 1 Week Stay May 22- Sept. 2, 2024 Week $4516.04 4 Nights $2772.00 / 5 Nights $3355.00 6 Nights $3938.00 $500.00 Security Deposit
Pets Allowed: 2 dog $25.00 per night with a maximum $100.00 charge for the week + $200.00 pet security deposit

4 reviews

  1. Spent 3 days with “gal pals”. Extraordinary property. Felt very safe and everything we could possibly need was there. Great base location for our Door County ventures including the wine tour, lighthouse tour and Washington Island adventure. Will be planning our 2021 summer event soon.

  2. Quiet, convenient waterfront

    One week family retreat blending children, teens, adults and seniors. Good K and DR space for breakfast/dinner. Everyone out and about with individual plans for the day reconvening for the evening meal. Excellent top floor BR with ensuite MBA. Three BRs with patio opening to the grounds flowing down to the waterfront. Comfort inside and lawn furniture outside. Fine water views and sunsets. Highly recommended.

  3. Tons of FUN!!!

    6 girlfriends celebrating 50+ years of friendship! 5 stars for Papa’s Bayside! So convenient to everything we did, beautiful views and sunsets, well furnished, pride of ownership — the list goes on.

    As the ringleader with a 30+ year career in the travel industry, KUDOS to J R Vacation Rentals as well for the ease of check-in/out and their attention to detail during the rental process.

    We had a BLAST and HIGHLY RECOMMEND both Papa’s Bayside and J R Vacation Rentals for you Door County Vacations.

  4. Our extended family of nine people stayed at Papa’s Bayside for a week and we loved it. This beautiful house is in a wonderful location, right on the shore of Green Bay but close enough to the town of Sturgeon Bay that it is easy to run out for groceries, etc. The house is very well maintained and equipped with everything we needed. Super clean and comfortable. JR Rental was wonderful to work with, and although we didn’t have any problems at all, it was really nice to know they were nearby in case anything came up – I think it is a big advantage to deal with a local rental company.

Rate and write a review

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.