Bay Fish Inn

· · 4 bedrooms · 2 bathrooms · 1920 sq ft

Water enthusiasts will delight in the location of Bay Fish Inn! This spacious rental is located on the channel of Sturgeon Bay, conveniently located half way between Lake Michigan and the waters of Green Bay. The beautiful yard overlooks the peaceful water setting and your own private dock with a fire pit at the shores edge. There is plenty of room for you to dock your boat. The boat lift is not to be used by renters. Only a short drive to downtown Sturgeon Bay or you can bike into town or Potawatomi State Park, located just down the road. A spacious gathering place for families or a group of fishermen! In 2019 a 50 inch SMART TV was added to the living room, also a heated garage is now available to store ATV’s, ice fishing equipment, bikes or other outside toys. No vehicle parking in the garage. Very close to Otumba park for swimming, tennis and children’s play area.

Maximum Occupancy:

Main Floor has open concept living room, dining room and kitchen.

Bathrooms: 1 Shower only; 1 Tub and Shower combo


2nd level: 3 Queens

3rd level: Queen and Full Futon

Pet Friendly:
Water access:
Write a review Review Bookmark this listing Bookmark

Availability calendar

Dates in Yellow are Tentatively Reserved. Dates in Red are Booked. All other dates are open.

Make inquiry now


  • **Furnishing and decor may change without notice.
  • **Sheets and towels not included.
  • 32' Dock
  • Alarm Clock(s)
  • Beautifully Landscaped
  • Blu Ray DVD Player
  • Board Games
  • Breakfast Bar
  • Breakfast Bar ( 2 bar stools)
  • Bumpers on dock
  • Cable TV (Basic)
  • Close to Downtown Shopping and Restaurants in Sturgeon Bay
  • Coffee Maker ( Flat filter)
  • Crock Pot
  • Deck
  • Deck (At Water)
  • Dishwasher
  • Exterior Power Outlets
  • Fans (Ceiling)
  • Fire Pit
  • Garage (1 Stall)
  • Garbage Disposal
  • Grill (Gas)
  • Hair Dryer
  • Hardwood Floors (Partial)
  • Iron
  • Ironing Board
  • Life Jackets
  • Microwave
  • Outdoor Furniture
  • Parking for boats/trailers
  • Patio
  • Picnic Table
  • Power on dock and in driveway for recharging
  • Puzzles
  • Skylights
  • Toaster
  • Water Accessible
  • Water View
  • WIFI
North Duluth Place
Sturgeon Bay 54235
Get directions
Year Round Rental Rates Peak Season June 1 -September 6, 2021 ***Special dates for this property*** 5 Nights minimum Week $1970.84 6 Nights $1886.30 5 Nights $1618.58 Off Season Rates September 7, 2021 - Dec 31, 2021 3 Nights minimum Week $1729.29 3 Nights $968.41 4 Nights $1197.88 / 5 Nights $1427.35 Winter January 1 - April 30, 2021 Week - 1673.55 3 Nights - $941.94 / 4 Nights - $1162.58 5 Nights - $1383.23 / 6 Nights - $1603.87 Security Deposit - $400.00 1 dog allowed Dog rates: $25.00 per day $100.00 maximum + $200.00 pet security deposit

5 reviews


    I have used this great place to fish out of many times in the last 2 yrs and I can tell you its an amazing fishery , I have caught a 31″ walleye directly out from the dock on the channel edge and have caught 22″ smallies on ” The Flats ” and on Greenbay having some 60 fish days ! Musky and Big Northern are there too if you concentrate on them. Town is 2 miles away and you can also access some great rest/bars from the water ! The house is all set up to handle all you need ! Green Bay is an AWESOME FISHERY and Lake Michigan for Salmon and Trout is only a 6 mile boat ride .

  2. We thoroughly enjoyed staying here. It has plenty of great space, nice views on the water and a nice little yard for pets or kids to play in. The place feels like a home away from home. We also enjoyed the proximity to Sturgeon Bay while still feeling like outside the city. Just a short walk down the road is Potawatomi State Park, which is great for hiking and views of the water.

  3. All I can say is...WOW

    We were thrilled for our trip when we booked with JR Vacation Rentals. The staff was excellent and was happy to help with any questions we had! This home is gorgeous to say the least! Spacious, tidy, and just beautiful inside, not to mention the views from the back porch facing the water…WOW! The firepit in the backyard was the perfect spot to relax with our friends and family. Don’t hesitate, book this home!

  4. Wonderful home on the water 💦

    Lovely Well appointed home on water ! Our family enjoyed the large yard & fire pit near water. We kept our 25’ boat at the dock with was ideal for sunset cruises . Only drawbacks – no air conditioning , no washer & dryer & step hill to property with lots of steps .

  5. Best vacation ever.

    We had the best time renting this property. We had our Florida family come up and stay with us in this wonderful house. There was 9 people and we absolutely loved the huge kitchen table. Ever night or rainy day was spent playing games . The yard was plenty big and all of the guys fished off the dock. Swimming was great. It surely was a sad day when we had to leave. Would definitely recommend.

Rate and write a review

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.